by Addison Wiggin - February 18, 201
- S&P up 100%, fastest doubling since 1936... The 5 tells you what The Wall Street Journal won't
- How the president gets away with saying, "We will not be adding more to the national debt"
- Two things you haven't been told about the protests in Wisconsin
- Silver smashes $32, as mints begin rationing supply
- Readers weigh in on whether "capitalism" has destroyed the middle class
We've been remiss. We made passing mention of a milestone yesterday, but failed to give it its due.
As of this week, the S&P 500 has doubled from its March 2009 low, the infamous 666.
The Wall Street Journal was quick to note that it took place in just 707 days -- the fastest doubling of the S&P since 1936. Back then, it was a mere 501 days.
The Dow has a few hundred more points to go before it reaches the same milestone… but it's climbed in less than two years from a low of 6,547 to 12,318 today:

That, indeed, looks similar to a chart of the Dow from September 1934-October 1936. In just over two years, the Dow doubled from 87 to 174:

What the Journal failed to note was what happened after that 100% climb in 1936. Let's widen the scope a bit.

Ugh… After reaching that double in October 1936, the Dow topped out in March 1937… pulled back… came within about 5% of that top again in August 1937… and then plunged by March 1938 back to where it was three years before.
This was the infamous "Depression within the Depression." As went the stock market, so went the economy. Whatever gains had been goosed by New Deal spending evaporated.
By 1939, Treasury Secretary Henry Morgenthau conceded to Congress: "We are spending more money than we have ever spent before, and it does not work... After eight years of this administration, we have just as much unemployment as when we started... and an enormous debt, to boot."
We're not saying history is destined to repeat itself. But the parallels are pretty obvious, and ominous. And there's a modern-day twist.
"We will not be adding more to the national debt," declared President Obama on Tuesday, speaking of his proposed 2012 budget, and its projections over the next 10 years.
"It's loose rhetoric," counters Robert Bixby, our Tab-drinking acquaintance from the Concord Coalition and I.O.U.S.A. fame. "It's literally not true."
See, the president is relying on the notion that spending would come into balance with revenues by 2017 -- something he and his aides call "primary balance." But their idea of spending excludes something very important -- interest on the national debt.
That's not insignificant. It was 4.6% of federal spending in fiscal 2010. But in the fantasy world of "primary balance," it doesn't count.
In the real world… and we're using the White House's own figures here… we'd still add $627 billion to the national debt in 2017, all in interest expense. By 2018, the annual cost of interest on the debt would exceed that of Medicare. And from 2017-2021, interest payments would total $4.5 trillion.
Which would balloon the national debt to $26.3 trillion. (As of this morning, it's $14.1 trillion.)
Indeed, interest payments on the national debt will quadruple over the next decade… once again, that's going by the White House's own projections. It would amount to $2,500 for every man, woman, and child… per year.
And that's assuming interest rates don't rise dramatically. This most hilarious part of the White House projections is this: Rates on 10-year Treasury paper are supposed to climb from 3% this year to 3.6% next year… reaching 5.3% by 2017.
Um… Somebody should have picked up the phone to Tim Geithner before putting this out. Or maybe glanced up at CNBC. 10-year Treasuries have been around 3.6% all this week.
If the Chinese -- who alone hold nearly 10% of all U.S. Treasury debt -- decide the United States has become a bigger risk, for which they want higher rates to compensate, all bets are off.
If they realize the White House is so clueless as to assert today's interest rates are 600 basis points lower than they actually are… they'll demand those higher rates immediately.
Of course, denial about a dire fiscal situation can take many forms. At the Wisconsin statehouse, it looks like this.

You've seen the pictures. You know that the new Republican governor wants to strip the public employee unions of their collective bargaining authority. And you know the result: Madison public schools are closed for the third straight day because so many teachers called out sick. Milwaukee joined them today.
Now for a couple of things you might not know. First, sympathy for the protesters outside the public employee unions is decidedly lacking… at least if the call-ins to Wisconsin Public Radio today are any indication.
"Get out of your Dane County mind-set!" one caller screamed. Dane County is home to the state capital and the University of Wisconsin's main campus. Callers were also upset with the legislature's Democratic minority. It remains holed up at a hotel in Rockford, Ill. -- outside the reach of the state troopers.
No quorum, no vote on the governor's plan.
Something else you may not know: Somewhere along the line, someone made some horrible decisions running Wisconsin's pension funds. According to David Cay Johnston of Tax.com, 15% of employee contributions get eaten up in fees to Wall Street.
Maybe the unions should redirect their ire? About 1,000 miles to the east?
The S&P 500 is adding to its 100% gain from the March 2009 low… if only a bit. It's up a point, to 1,341. The Dow is up too.
Traders are shrugging off news that China is once again raising its banks' reserve requirements in a feeble attempt to curb inflation.
Silver has smashed through the $32 barrier to reach another post-1980 high. The spot price as we write is $32.67.
The Royal Canadian Mint is starting to ration sales of Silver Maple Leafs. The Austrian Mint is doing likewise with its Silver Philharmonics. No such move yet by the U.S. Mint… which hasn't updated its sales figures since we last reported them on Wednesday. The February total still appears unlikely to eclipse January's record.
Compared to silver, gold looks like a laggard -- up just $5, to $1,390. And that trend is likely to continue -- for reasons we make clear in this report for Outstanding Investments.
"Many thanks to readers who sent emails this week," adds Outstanding Investments editor Byron King, "congratulating me on the news that the Hulbert Financial Digest ranked Outstanding Investments as its No. 1-performing investment newsletter over the past 10 years.
"That's No. 1 out of 99 newsletters that Hulbert tracks. Hulbert calculated that in the first decade of the millennium, OI delivered an annualized return of 21.7%. The other 98 newsletters were... well, let's not discuss the competition except to say that they didn't deliver 21.7%.
"So what's the 'secret sauce,' the editorial theme for OI? Hey, it's not a state secret or anything. I sure bang the drum with every note I send you. 'Real' assets -- precious metals, energy, hard and soft commodities -- are getting more and more scarce. In other words, the low-hanging fruit of this world is gone. If you understand that, you're halfway there."
Even better, we offer two other services that aim to profit from the same trend. Byron's premium service Energy & Scarcity Investor recommended three rare earth plays on Sept. 3. He's already recommended selling two for gains of 109% and 177%. The third is up 147% and counting. Another "technology metal" play is up 217%. And there's an offshore oil play up well over 480% (16% just yesterday).
We don't want to overlook Alan Knuckman's Resource Trader Alert… where just today readers closed out a soybean meal play for 95% gains. That's in addition to gains in the last six months including wheat for 217%, gold for 221% and corn for 273%.
Next week, we'll offer access to all three of these services as a "package deal" for a remarkably low one-time fee. We call it the Resource Reserve -- everything you need to profit from "real" assets. We haven't opened up membership in four years.
Only 200 slots will be available, because this package deal also includes admission to the annual Agora Financial Investment Symposium in Vancouver.
We expect these new Resource Reserve slots to go immediately when we open access to the public on Wednesday. But if you'd like dibs, we'll put you on a priority list that gives you the chance to sign up a day early. There's no obligation… Just drop us your email address here and you'll get an early invite on Tuesday.
"Why don't you just come out and admit," a reader demands, "there isn't one American in 1,000 who knows what inflation is and that the CPI is yet another big fraud? He goes on to define inflation: 'Inflation is an increase in the supply of money and credit in an economy relative to the amount of goods and services produced.'
"The SYMPTOM of inflation is rising prices, not inflation itself. The U.S. money supply has doubled, and probably tripled, since 2000, and Obama, but everything you buy today isn't 2-3 times more expensive now than in 2000.
"The downward pressure on prices, due to our crippled economy, has mitigated somewhat the huge INCREASE in commodity costs occurring at the same time. Profit margins of producers are cut to the bone; staff do not get wage increases they otherwise would get; layoffs of superfluous staff abound; and as you said, people are eating hamburgers, rather than steaks.
"Sorry this email is so long. I should write a book. Only no one reads books anymore. Many of them can't read at all!"
The 5: Nothing to "admit" on our part… but we concede that preaching to the choir can feel good now and then, doesn't it?
"I think it's incorrect," a reader asserts, responding to the suggestion yesterday that capitalism is destroying the middle class and must be "controlled."
"Capitalism is what was behind our country's growth from the Revolutionary War up until our victory in World War II. The advent of, and the ever increasing, socialist programs our government now hands out, is destroying capitalism, and is responsible for the decline of our country's middle class."
"I could write a book on what the government of our country has done to damage capitalism in our country, but there are plenty of them available to read as it is. I read Financial Reckoning Day in 2005, long before I became a member of Agora Financial Reserve, and I would suggest that plus Empire of Debt, Economics in One Lesson, The Big Short and The Global Debt Trap as must-reads to truly get a glimpse of what has happened to our country, who is responsible and what we can look forward to."
The 5: The "problem," if there is one, is that we don't practice the type of capitalism that delivered prosperity to the nation. We practice a degenerate form of social welfare and call it capitalism, whereby half the country expects to live off the fruits of the other half's labor. And given their penchant for voting, that's not likely to turn around anytime soon.
In an email exchange yesterday, Bill Bonner, my esteemed co-author in Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt, continued his tirade against "zombification":
"Harvard was pretending to educate," he writes, referring to the fact that 90%-plus of Harvard's students graduated with honors back in 2002. "Troops were pretending to protect civilization in Afghanistan... QE2 pretends to be real money... the SEC pretends to protect the little guy...all zombies... sell-outs to the system... the degenerate social welfare capitalism of the 21st century."
[Ed. Note: You can get any of the above-mentioned books for 20% off at Laissez Faire Books. Just use the coupon code E401M206.]
"I'd look at it another way," writes another reader on the subject. "There will always be the very rich and powerful and there will always be the very poor -- whilst capitalism was allowed to thrive unfettered by the meddling and corrupting political and financial elite, it created a middle class.
"It is the lack of checks on those elite that is destroying the middle classes now, not capitalism, so let's be careful before we decide who the mobs should target -- capitalism or the Ben Bernankes of this world -- after all, the penalty according to the Founding Fathers for debasing the coinage was, I believe, execution."
The 5: We suspect some classical liberals thought the same way you did in France in 1789. We also suspect most of them didn't live much beyond 1792. Mobs acquire a mind of their own.
Have a good weekend,
Addison Wiggin
The 5 Min. Forecast
P.S. "Nicaragua suffers from its past," writes Chris Mayer to his Capital & Crisis subscribers from here at Rancho Santana. "'Nicaragua ha sufrido mucho,' as the saying goes ('Nicaragua has suffered a lot').
"The Sandinistas ran the country in the 1980s. They had some bad ideas about how things should work, and Nicaragua devolved into the usual state of communist enterprises.
"One of the books I packed along for this trip is titled My Car in Managua, a lighthearted look at living in post-revolutionary Nicaragua in the 1980s. Author Forrest Colburn, who was a frequent visitor and lived in Nicaragua for a year, tells many engaging vignettes about what it was like.
"For example, the Sandinistas nationalized the country's largest grocery chain. Without market pricing and incentives driving it, the stores suffered. There were often shortages of basics like milk, eggs, rice, beans and the like.
"The stores also fumbled around badly when it came to making choices about what they did carry. Colburn writes how a store could routinely be out of cheese, but have an aisle's worth of cheese graters. Or how they might be out of toilet paper and toothpaste, but carry plenty of imported fruit preserves and jams -- in a country that produces an abundance of tropical fruit.
"Other businesses struggled too. McDonald's had a restaurant in Managua. The manager there had to improvise. When he couldn't get potatoes for fries, he sold fried cassava. When he ran out of lettuce, he used cabbage. When there was no American cheese, he'd use some other kind of cheese. This upset McDonald's, which prides itself on the uniformity of its product, no matter where in the world you find it.
"Colburn says the phrase 'no hay' became a kind of national refrain. It means, 'there isn't any.' Frequently, there wasn't much of anything."
Colburn tells a local joke. A poor Nicaraguan dies and goes before St. Peter, who tells the poor Nicaraguan that he will have to go to hell. But he gets to choose whether he wants to go to capitalist hell or communist hell.
"What's the difference?" the poor Nicaraguan asks.
"In both, they drop you in a vat, feed your manure and bang you over the head with a shovel," St. Peter tells him.
"So which one should I choose?"
"I'd choose communist hell," St. Peter advises him. "Sometimes they lose the shovels or run out of manure."
We still have room for Reserve members for our next Chill Weekend in June. For the dates and other essential info, check out this invite.
P.P.S. U.S. markets are closed Monday for Presidents' Day. We'll be back in the saddle in Baltimore on Tuesday.


